Phone answered 24/7 · Cleveland, OH and nearby communities

Call 24/7: (216) 238-6265
Doan Brook Water ResponseWater Damage Help · Cleveland, OH

What Is a Bad Faith Insurance Claim and When Does It Apply?

Last updated October 31, 2026

The short answer

Defining Bad Faith

Bad faith means your insurance company fails to honor its side of the policy. Examples include refusing to investigate, denying a claim without reason, or offering far less than the damage warrants. It also covers unreasonable delays that leave your home worse off.

In water damage situations, bad faith often appears after a burst pipe or flood. The insurer might ignore evidence from your own inspection or push you to accept a low settlement. You have the right to challenge that, but you need proof of unfair conduct.

  • Denying a claim without a valid policy reason
  • Ignoring or mishandling your documented evidence
  • Delaying payment without explanation
  • Offering a settlement far below the actual repair cost
  • Failing to communicate about your claim status
  • Misrepresenting policy language to avoid coverage

When It Applies

Bad faith applies only when the loss is covered by your policy. If your policy excludes flooding or certain types of water damage, the insurer can deny it without acting in bad faith. You must first establish that the damage falls within your coverage.

It also applies when the insurer acts unreasonably. For example, if you provide clear photos and a professional inspection report, but the insurer still refuses to pay without explanation, that could be bad faith. Keep all records of your communications and documents.

Evidence You Should Gather

Strong evidence helps build a bad faith case. Save every email, letter, and note from phone calls with your insurer. Take photos of the damage before any cleanup, and keep receipts for any temporary repairs you paid for yourself.

A written inspection report from a water damage professional can be valuable. It documents the extent of the damage and the likely repair costs. That report gives you a concrete baseline to compare against the insurer's offer.

  • Photos and videos of the water damage
  • Copies of your insurance policy and endorsements
  • All written correspondence with the insurer
  • A log of phone calls with dates and summaries
  • Receipts for emergency repairs or temporary lodging
  • The inspection report from a water damage pro

Steps to Take First

Before pursuing a bad faith claim, review your policy carefully. Understand what is covered and what is excluded. If you believe the denial is wrong, ask the insurer to explain the specific policy language they relied on.

Document everything from the start. After a water loss, call your insurer quickly and get a claim number. Then hire a local water damage pro to inspect and document the damage. That report can support your position if disputes arise.

Water damage does not wait

Phones are answered 24/7 for Cleveland and nearby communities.

Call Now (216) 238-6265

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to file a bad faith claim?

The time limit, called the statute of limitations, varies by state. Check your state's law or consult a qualified professional who handles insurance disputes. Acting quickly is wise because evidence and memories fade. Your insurance policy may also have deadlines for filing an appeal.

Can I file a bad faith claim if my claim was denied?

A denial alone does not mean bad faith. You need evidence that the denial was unreasonable or dishonest, such as ignoring your documentation or misreading the policy. If you have that proof, a bad faith claim may apply.

What damages can I recover in a bad faith claim?

If bad faith is proven, you might recover the amount you were owed, plus additional damages for emotional distress or legal costs. The exact amounts depend on state law and the specifics of your case. A qualified attorney can explain what applies.

Call Now (216) 238-6265